Fullmetal Alchemist

Fullmetal Alchemist

鋼の錬金術師
2003 -2004 Bones MBS 51 episodes Completed
Action Adventure Drama
▹ Discuss in Forums ▹ Related Articles
Details & Synopsis
The year is 1910, approximately. The country is Amestris, approximately. Two boys in a rural town teach themselves alchemy from their absent father's books and decide to do the one thing every alchemical text agrees cannot be done, human transmutation, the resurrection of the dead. Their mother. They are children. They do not survive the attempt intact.
Edward Elric loses his right arm and left leg. Alphonse Elric loses everything, his entire body, seized by the Gate, leaving behind only a soul that Ed binds to a suit of armour in the seconds before he loses consciousness. The exchange is the series' foundation and its recurring nightmare: the law of equivalent exchange, the principle that underpins all alchemy, applied to the thing it was never meant to touch. They paid. They did not get what they paid for.
Produced by Bones and directed by Seiji Mizushima, Fullmetal Alchemist aired on MBS from 2003 to 2004. Fifty-one episodes. It began adapting Hiromu Arakawa's manga faithfully and then, as the weekly production overtook the still-running manga, gradually moved into an original storyline. What followed is one of the most remarkable pivots in anime history: the production team, with Arakawa's blessing and a handful of her discarded plot threads, invented their own story. Their own villain. Their own ending.
The ending they arrived at is darker than Brotherhood's. More ambiguous. More interested in the cost of the boys' choices than in the resolution of the world's politics. Dante. The Gate. What is on the other side of it. A finale that refuses the comfort of restoration and insists that some debts cannot be paid back, they can only be carried forward.
Brotherhood is the manga. Faithful, complete, structurally confident, the story Arakawa intended. This is something else. A parallel history. A what-if that the people who made it took entirely seriously. Both versions are essential. They are not the same show wearing the same premise. They are two writers asking the same question and arriving at different answers about what human beings owe each other and what alchemy, the science of transformation, of making one thing into another, actually costs when the thing being transformed is a person.
Watch both. Then argue about which one broke you worse.
Alt Title 鋼の錬金術師
Studio Bones
Network MBS
Aired 2003 - 2004
Episodes 51
Genre Action, Adventure, Drama
Status Completed
← All lore

Ishbal & the Military

How to Read Ishbal

Ishbal Is the Past That Keeps Becoming the Present

SPOILER!
The Ishbal war is not background lore the anime expects you to memorize once and file away. It is the event connecting Scar, Mustang, Marcoh, Kimblee, the State Alchemist program and eventually Liore.

The useful question is not only what happened in Ishbal. It is why so many people in the present are still making decisions inside the shape that war left behind.

The War

The Military Turns Alchemy Into State Violence

Episodes 14–16 · the brothers learn what the silver watch means to Ishbalans

Edward becomes a State Alchemist because the title gives him access. Scar sees the same title and remembers what State Alchemists were used for during the extermination campaign.

State Alchemists Become Human Weapons

SPOILER!

Ishbal · military orders backed by alchemical force

The military deploys State Alchemists into Ishbal because individual alchemists can do the work of artillery, demolition teams and execution squads with terrifying speed.

That is the history sitting behind Scar's habit of targeting State Alchemists specifically. To him the silver watch does not primarily mean scholarship. It marks somebody belonging to the institution that weaponized alchemy against his people.
Why it matters
Edward joins the military believing he can use the institution without becoming what it has been. Ishbal is the evidence that the institution has made the same bargain with talented alchemists before.
Edward Elric Roy Mustang Scar

Dr. Marcoh: The Researcher Who Learned What His Work Was For

SPOILER!

Philosopher's Stone research · guilt after Ishbal

Marcoh is one of the first adults to show Edward what it looks like when useful research reaches the military and stops belonging only to the researcher.

His work on Philosopher's Stone material becomes tied to Ishbal, and his guilt is why he abandons the military rather than continuing to treat the work as an abstract scientific achievement.
Why it matters
Marcoh is not merely a source who points Ed toward another clue. He is a preview of the question waiting for Edward: if your research helps the State hurt people, how much does it matter that hurting people was not your personal goal?
Edward Elric

Zolf Kimblee: The State Alchemist Who Does Not Need an Excuse

SPOILER!

Crimson Alchemist · violence without Mustang's guilt

Kimblee matters because the anime refuses to make every State Alchemist from Ishbal morally identical.

Mustang carries the war like a wound. Marcoh runs from what his research became. Kimblee enjoys the destructive freedom military alchemy gives him and treats human beings as opportunities to demonstrate it.
Why it matters
If Mustang represents guilt inside the system, Kimblee represents the system finding exactly the kind of person who enjoys what it asks him to do.
Zolf Kimblee Roy Mustang Scar

Scar & His Brother

Scar Inherits More Than His Brother's Arm

Ishbalan alchemy · grief · the unfinished Stone

Scar's right arm is both a weapon and the surviving piece of research his brother left behind. The revenge campaign and the Philosopher's Stone plot therefore grow from the same family history.

Scar's Brother: The Researcher Behind the Arm

SPOILER!

A dead man whose work keeps directing the living

Scar's brother studies alchemy deeply enough to cross cultural and religious boundaries that many Ishbalans distrust. During the war, that research becomes bound to Scar through the transmuted arm he receives from him.

The arm gives Scar destructive alchemy he would never otherwise use in the same way and eventually becomes part of the array behind his Philosopher's Stone plan.
Why it matters
Scar believes he is avenging Ishbal, but the tool that lets him do it comes from a brother who was already trying to understand the same alchemical system Scar condemns.
Scar

Scar Stops at Deconstruction Because Destruction Is the Point

SPOILER!

Right arm · incomplete transmutation

Scar's signature attack performs the destructive stage of alchemy without continuing into reconstruction. He reads the structure of what he touches and breaks it apart.
The Breakdown
This is alchemy turned into assassination by refusing to finish the normal process. Scar does not need to build something new from a State Alchemist's body. He only needs the existing structure to stop holding together.
Scar

Mustang After Ishbal

Mustang Decides the Only Useful Direction Is Up

Guilt turned into ambition

Roy Mustang does not leave the military after Ishbal. He decides to climb it.

Mustang: Staying Inside the Machine on Purpose

SPOILER!

The Flame Alchemist after Ishbal

Mustang's ambition makes more sense once Ishbal is understood. He has seen what orders from above can make State Alchemists do, and his answer is to reach a position where he can change who gives those orders.

That does not erase what he did. The 2003 anime is more interested in the tension: Mustang's plan to reform the State depends on continuing to use the rank, authority and people that the State gives him.
Why it matters
Mustang's guilt and ambition are not competing character traits. The ambition is what he decided to do with the guilt.
Roy Mustang

Liore Repeats the Pattern

Liore Starts Looking Like Ishbal on Purpose

Episodes 39–42 · conflict engineered into an ingredient

When the anime returns to Liore, the earlier war stops being history and becomes a template somebody is trying to recreate.

Rose: The Civilian at the Center of Everyone Else's War

SPOILER!

Liore after Cornello

Rose begins the series as somebody Cornello can control by promising to return the person she lost. When the story returns to Liore, she is living inside the consequences of the power vacuum and violence that followed.

She does not become important because she suddenly understands the military, Scar or the Homunculi better than everyone else. She matters because the people making grand plans keep using a city full of ordinary lives like hers as terrain.
Why it matters
Liore stops the Ishbal parallel from becoming an abstract political comparison. Rose gives the repeated pattern a civilian face the audience already knows.

The Military Marches Toward a Massacre Somebody Else Has Already Prepared

SPOILER!

Liore · the same machinery, a new city

Military escalation around Liore creates exactly the kind of concentrated death that Philosopher's Stone research requires.

Scar understands what is happening and responds by building his own transmutation around the approaching soldiers while trying to move civilians out of the intended sacrifice zone.
What changed
The Ishbal lesson becomes active. Characters are no longer remembering how a massacre was exploited for alchemy. They are watching the same structure being assembled again and choosing what role they will play inside it.
Scar Edward Elric Alphonse Elric

Scar Reverses the Victims Without Rejecting the Equation

SPOILER!

Episode 42 · the Stone is completed

Scar turns the military force entering Liore into the human cost of the Philosopher's Stone and completes the transmutation through Alphonse.

The revenge is understandable because of Ishbal. It is also deliberately uncomfortable.
Why it matters
Scar's final answer still accepts the premise that enough human lives can become material for a greater purpose. He changes who is sacrificed, not the logic that permits sacrifice.
Scar Alphonse Elric

What Ishbal Leaves Behind

Nobody Gets to Leave Ishbal in the Past

Scar · Mustang · Marcoh · the brothers

Different survivors make different promises after Ishbal, and the final third of FMA 2003 is where those promises collide.

Edward Cannot Treat the State as a Neutral Tool Anymore

SPOILER!

The silver watch means something whether he likes it or not

Ed never becomes responsible for Ishbal simply because he later joins the military. But once he knows the history, he can no longer pretend the institution behind his research access is morally irrelevant.
Why it matters
That is one of the quiet changes between early and late Edward. He starts by asking whether the military can help him reach the Stone. He ends up asking what helping the military makes him part of.
Edward Elric